Tucked away beneath the Inn is the Captain’s Cellar, an intimate milieu for informal gatherings. Enjoy a glass of vintage wine in front of our cozy fireplace, surrounded by the original field stone walls built by the Captain.  The Inn boasts a selection of Long Island wines, Jedediah’s own label, as well as the world’s choicest vintages.  Many wines are offered for less than $30.

Captain's Menu
......................................................................................

NY Strip Sirloin Ceviche
horseradish-yuzu vinaigrette, cilantro-corn salad
~12~

Tuna Sashimi
grilled pineapple, spicy mayo, seaweed salad
~12~

Striped Bass Carpaccio
clementine-carrot citronette
~13~

Daily Market Oysters (3)
sangrita shooters
~10~
supplement Grey Goose vodka or Patron Silver tequila
~+5~

House Salad
mache, arugula, radicchio, watercress, chayote, pomegranate,
nectarines, garlic-cumin vinaigrette
~14~

Fried Calamari
yellow cornmeal, sweet and sour fig sauce,
grape tomato-corn-mint salad
~13~

Jedediah Hawkins House Burger
~10~

Guacamole
made to order, served with tortilla chips
~10~

Lobster Roll
(Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays only)
lobster salad, grilled potato bun, carrot slaw
~19~